What is it like to negotiate with Russian representatives concerning the war in Ukraine?
This question has piqued considerable interest following multiple latest sessions of ceasefire talks, which until now seemed to produce minimal fruit four years since the full-scale invasion.
Another phase of American-facilitated discussions is likely to occur in the Swiss city in the coming days. Ahead of it, a key participant of the Ukrainian leadership's negotiating team, Sergiy Kyslytsya, who has been involved in recent military-to-military talks, has shared his viewpoint.
As stated by the negotiator, these dealings are professional and mostly devoid of the type of political and historical posturing seen elsewhere by Russian leadership.
"Military officials possess a better grasp of the realities in the combat zone," he remarked during a meeting on Monday morning.
"The question remains whether they [the Russians] are able, or not, of relaying information directly…free from altering or distorting the information," he continued.
It is not an simple thing to try to halt a war. The nature of the front line in the Donbas region - where thousands of unmanned aerial vehicles patrol and strike over a vast so-called "grey zone" separating the opposing forces, while two hundred thousand local residents still live in the "fortress belt" urban areas of the eastern region - makes the practical process of disengagement extremely complicated.
"It is essential to have a precise set of guidelines and protocols," Kyslytsya explained, "along with a method to confirm and oversee."
The Role of International Parties
A great deal of these preparations, he noted, is complete, partly due to the close involvement of US officials, such as General Alexus Grynkewich and Dan Driscoll.
It's obviously not in Kyiv's interest to disparage representatives of the American administration, but when Kyslytsya compliments the American team for its work, he sounds genuine.
"We must acknowledge the US side for their dedication and their perseverance," he states, "because they attend the meetings non-stop. They not only watch…they ask inquiries and they listen to our responses."
The negotiator was equally complimentary about the contributions played by the former president's adviser, whom he described as "experienced", and wealthy envoy Steve Witkoff, whom he characterized as "a much wiser person than the simplified image often presented in the media".
The US, Kyslytsya said, will undertake a critical role in overseeing any potential truce, with capabilities including orbital and other types of advanced monitoring.
"We need an entity who will play the role of adjudication, for the reason that if there is a breach there should be a neutral actor that is solid [and] respected."
Previous and Present Oversight Challenges
For eight years before the major offensive in 2022, this oversight function was played by the Organisation for Security and Cooperation in Europe - a group whose restricted means and lack of enforcement mechanisms made it mostly unable of preventing an escalation.
"That was no small feat [for them] just to operate two UAVs airborne above the area," Kyslytsya said. "It's kind of the stone age period in contrast with what we have now."
By contrast, latest analyses suggest that as many as 12,000 unmanned aircraft are active over the urban center of Pokrovsk at any one time.
A Personal Perspective on Confronting the Opposition
Inquired about his ability to negotiate directly from emissaries from a head of state in the Russian government who has shown readiness to expend more than a million-plus of his own men to subjugate its neighbor, Kyslytsya, also a former UN ambassador, provided his answer.
He told that he'd had a long time of practice.
"I witnessed far more difficult situations. I spent five years in at the UN, three of them before the full-scale invasion. I would sit in the room with the adversary on a regular basis."
One evening is seared in his memory: the eve of the invasion.
During an emergency UN Security Council session, convened to discuss the looming threat in the country, the ambassador got word that his homeland was under attack.
At the same time, seven time zones to the eastward in Kyiv, the first far-off detonations signaled as Russia's total assault on Ukraine commenced.
Amid scenes of intense drama, Kyslytsya tried to persuade his Russian counterpart, the Russian envoy, to call his boss, Foreign Minister Sergei Lavrov, to obtain assurances that Moscow's forces would not cross the border.
"I've already said everything I know today," Nebenzia responded, according to his Ukrainian colleague. "I'm not going to wake Minister Lavrov at this hour."
Everyone's lives changed at that moment. The diplomat remained at the UN for an additional period prior to going back to Kyiv.
The Path Forward
If the negotiating teams reconvene in Geneva this week, he will participate, still working through the details and mechanics of a halt in fighting but anticipating all the while for the most important part of the jigsaw to fall into place.
"The war might be ended by simply a single order of one person to his top general," he stated.
"But apparently, the Kremlin dictator [Vladimir Putin] is not prepared for stopping the conflict at present."